Tangled up in family ties

Growing up around fights, illegal activities and broken relationships, crime becomes the norm. For these young men looking to move on from their past, their families, or lack thereof, might make it more difficult.

When Daniel* was nine, he ran away from home with just $2 in his pocket.

His stepfather abused him and his mother was a drug addict. Even when the police found him a year later, surviving with neighbourhood gangs, Daniel asked to be sent to a children’s home instead.

Throughout his teenage years, he was arrested for robbery, snatch theft and rioting, and bounced around between institutions like Singapore Boys’ Home and Boys’ Town.

Now, the young man in his 20s has changed his life around and wants to be a social worker. It has been an arduous journey to reach this point — mostly because he had to walk it without his family.

A fighter from a broken family

Daniel’s mother had several marriages in his growing up years. With multiple caregivers in his early childhood, he never had a constant adult figure whom he is attached to, said Daniel’s former social worker from the children’s home.

With every one of his mother’s new partners came new half-siblings that would fight for his parents’ attention. The youth may have felt like an outcast as he is not part of the family unit, said the social worker who still stays in touch with Daniel today.

During weekends at the children’s home, no one visited him. He was not given home leave to meet his mother due to safety concerns.

His social worker, who has to be kept anonymous to protect Daniel’s identity, would bring him out for outings and meals while other children met their parents.

“Daniel always had a desire to have a normal and intact family, to be connected with someone. He was always very envious of boys with families, ” he said, adding that the youth often acted out because of frustration and jealousy.

Six months after he left the children’s home, the 13-year-old was arrested for robbery and rioting, and was sent to Boys’ Town - a residential home for boys - for a year of rehabilitation. 

According to him, his friends there came from broken families too. Trying to provide for themselves, they did ‘entrepreneurial activities’ to earn money — sneaking in things from outside to sell, and extorting money from other boys.

This got him into trouble, and he was soon sent to Boys’ Home. 

Things spiraled down even more, as he started attacking people for a loan shark. He could get up to $3000 each time, he said.

Boys’ Home could only keep him till he was 16 and he was eventually sent back to the children’s home he grew up in. This time, he became a dangjia there - meaning “head of the house” in Hokkien.

He would rather be known as the tough fighter than the person with a broken family, he said.

Going solo

An act of kindness eventually turned his life around. When he was 18, he was held in a police lockup for a drug trafficking case which he insists he was not involved in. 

Desperate, he tried to call his mother. She did not pick up.

His social worker was the only one who came to help. Touched, the young man decided he wanted to be like him and guide at-risk youth.

“For the first time, I felt hopeful,” he said.

Eventually, he was acquitted and could apply for a social work course in a tertiary institute. In his schooling days, he lived alone in a rented room. While other students studied at night or spent time with their families, he worked six days a week as a butler in a nightclub to put himself through school and pay rent.

Other than going out with his social worker and two old friends from Boys’ Town, he has gotten used to a solitary life.

He empathised deeply with migrant workers, whom he served while on a school internship.

“I think my heart always goes out to people who are not local,” he said.

"I think maybe it stems from me not feeling like... a sense of belonging here."

An open room

Fortunately, there are people willing to provide a place for ex-residents like Daniel with no home to return to.

Post-graduate students Ian and Marianne Chew, 32 and 29 respectively, had a spare room in their flat in Hougang. Led by their faith, and inspired by others in their community, the married couple hoped to put it to good use.

“As Christians, we asked God ‘can you use this place?’,” said Ian. “We can open the room for others to use, but in the past few years we haven’t had anyone to stay. Just no opportunity.”

Last year, after meeting The Last Resort — another couple who open their home to at-risk youth — Mr Chew found out about an 18-year-old who was about to be discharged from Boys’ Home.

Four years ago, the youth’s mother kicked him out of their home in Malaysia and sent him to Singapore. He got into trouble and was sent to Boys’ Home for 14 months. 

After his discharge, he had nowhere to go. The couple decided to welcome him into their home.

To protect his privacy, they requested that the youth's identity be anonymous in this report.

Becoming a family

Initially, it was hard to form a bond. The first two months seemed fine, until they realised he was hiding things from them. 

“Towards the end of the second or third month, we started to realise it was all a front,” said Mrs Chew. “There was actually so much that was going on underneath. 

He was having difficulties with applying to the Institute of Technical Education (ITE) and did not take responsibility for it.

It was only with help from his caseworkers that still checked in on him, and Ian and Marianne, that he finally got a spot.

On weekday evenings, the couple pray with him and talk to him about his day, but at other times, find it hard to give him advice or discipline him.

“We didn’t have the luxury of taking care of him when he was young,” said Mr Chew.  

“We don’t have the authority as parents or siblings, so we’re starting from scratch and trying to figure out where our relationship stands with him.”

This includes navigating his relationship with his mother, who comes to Singapore regularly to give him money. Recently, she gave Ian and Marianne a sum for her son monthly as allowance, to teach him how to manage his money better. 

Communication has been a struggle as they try to be his friends as well as authority figures. 

“How do we strike the balance with ‘I’m your friend and I really want to care for you, but I’m also your authority figure’,” said Ian. “Your friends don’t control your allowance.” 

Ian and Marianne Chew had a spare room that they were hoping to put to good use. With a desire to help others, they were open to welcoming anyone who needed it.

Ian and Marianne Chew had a spare room that they were hoping to put to good use. With a desire to help others, they were open to welcoming anyone who needed it.

A lasting influence 

For some youth offenders, their family’s presence is part of the problem.

At 15 years old, Jonathan* was charged for rioting with deadly weapons. 

“Do you want to know who I was rioting with?” He paused before answering. “It was my mum, my dad, and my younger brother.”

Jonathan’s family situation is complex. His mother, a drug addict, left his biological father when he was a toddler. Meanwhile, his stepfather is a heavyweight in a gang and ‘famous’ among rival groups, said Jonathan, who is now 22.

When he was 14, a group of strangers cornered him and taunted him, saying his stepfather was getting old and weak. 

“I told them to tell my father that, not me,” said Jonathan. “Then shit happened. He hit me and I got pissed off.” 

The next night, his stepfather led the family to hunt the men down. The youth watched as the older man sliced the stranger across the cheek with a chopper.

Both Jonathan and his stepfather were arrested. While the older man was sent to prison, the youth was given a two week detention order at Boys’ Home, a year in Boys’ Hostel and a year of probation at home.

His stepfather could not be reached for comment, but Jonathan’s ex-social worker Narasimman S/O Tivasiha Mani, who has worked with the youth for six years now, confirmed the fight.

Role models

Most children turn to their parents as role models. According to Dr Gregor Lim-Lange, an experienced clinical psychologist who has worked with troubled youth, children learn from their parents’ behaviours.

“Kids learn by observing,” he said. “If they see adults take drugs, be aggressive, or even drive their car too fast - in their eyes that’s normal. (They think) that’s how adults behave, so they are at risk of behaving similarly.”

As a child, when the family would go out for lunch at the coffee shop under their block, gang fights would break out.

“My brother was still a baby in a pram. We were eating at the table and suddenly somebody broke a bottle on my dad’s head. He got up and he and his friends started fighting,” recalled Jonathan. “I saw blood and punches being thrown.”

Jonathan said he witnessed at least five similar fights at meal times. Even though his stepfather warned him to stay away from gang activities, he grew up learning that he could solve problems with his fists.

Coming home

After serving his detention order at Boys’ Home, Jonathan went back home. When his stepfather returned from prison, everything seemed to return to normal. But ‘normal’ was far from pleasant.

“My brother and I were abused when we were younger,” Jonathan said with an awkward laugh, adding that the most recent incident happened last year.

Jonathan has been able to confide in Mr Narasimman to work through his abusive past. His stepfather is usually fine, but things get ugly if he drinks, said the social worker.

“My dad would beat my mum whenever he was drunk,” Jonathan recalls. “She was cheating on him… and would create a scene when she was either high or drunk.”

Mr Narasimman (right) watches over as Jonathan (left) gets his yoga pose rectified by the instructor. According to Mr Narasimman, Trybe collaborates with yoga and fitness institutions in Singapore to allow the boys to experience new activities monthly and keep them engaged. "Yoga and meditation is beneficial to the boys as it helps them to calm their minds, and to have better clarity when making decisions," he said.

Mr Narasimman (right) watches over as Jonathan (left) gets his yoga pose rectified by the instructor. According to Mr Narasimman, Trybe collaborates with yoga and fitness institutions in Singapore to allow the boys to experience new activities monthly and keep them engaged. "Yoga and meditation is beneficial to the boys as it helps them to calm their minds, and to have better clarity when making decisions," he said.

Since the start of 2019, his mother has not been living at home regularly.

According to Dr Lim-Lange, going back home to the original stressors can cause a child to regress and make it difficult for them to reintegrate.

“The child may have had all kinds of therapy, but the parents may not have,” said Dr Lim-Lange.

“If the family environment is still dysfunctional there’s a risk it can undermine (positive changes) anyway. If they’re critical or abusive, it undermines the therapy the kid may have received.”

Actively avoiding harm

Strangers still threaten their family. Now that his stepfather is getting older, Jonathan and his brother have to step in, but they try to de-escalate the situation. If that fails, they fight in his place but try to minimise the violence, said Jonathan.

Mr Narasimman would rather Jonathan steer clear of harm’s way. Though he has tried to help Jonathan move somewhere else, the young man wants to stay with his family.

So far, they’ve reached a compromise.

“I tell him not to provoke (his stepfather)... and try not to be in the house,” said Mr Narasimman.

To do this, Jonathan has thrown himself into sports. The fitness training student runs and works out almost every day and trains twice a week with his school’s rugby team.

When his stepfather retires, Jonathan wants to support him financially. But why help a man who has hurt him?

According to Mr Narasimman, this could be a ‘trauma bond’, a psychological effect common in abusive families.

“It is when you are traumatised but you want to be with the abuser because there is familiarity and comfort in abuse itself,” he explained.

But Jonathan does not see it that way. His stepfather loved him even though they did not share the same blood, he said.

“That’s one question everybody asks me - ‘why’,” Jonathan said. He paused before answering, “Love. That’s the only reason.”

*Names have been changed to protect their identities.

Of late, Jonathan has thrown himself into fitness to better himself and distance himself from his past of drinking and partying.

Of late, Jonathan has thrown himself into fitness to better himself and distance himself from his past of drinking and partying.

In order to clear his mind, he runs in the evening after school. On a particularly difficult night, he might go for a run as late as 2 a.m. in order to calm himself.

In order to clear his mind, he runs in the evening after school. On a particularly difficult night, he might go for a run as late as 2 a.m. in order to calm himself.